19 Comments
User's avatar
sarah dufrau's avatar

Yesss! This is so good. (Also as good a place as any to say that there's this bar we go to a lot where a lot of the bartenders are femmes with big muscles, which tbh is one of the reasons i like going there so much, but ive been lifting weights this summer JUST IN CASE any of them ever challenge me to an arm wrestle, not necessarily because i want to win but just so in this entirely imaginary situation i can at least put up a respectable showing 😂. Anyway to me that is also one meaning of "butch": live your life as if you might be challenged to an arm wrestling match by a pretty bartender at any given moment.)

Expand full comment
AKM's avatar

As an AFAB femme-presenting non-binary person who is most comfortable in pants but loves lipstick and eyeliner and MY BOOBS but is, in the words of the glorious Janet from The Good Place, "not a girl", this part gave me so much joy and I felt so seen: "It's an energy. It's a temperament. It's a demeanor. It's a thing you just know, and the best feeling in the whole world is when you can finally own it."

Expand full comment
Nancy Amazon's avatar

I love this for you. I love this for all of us.

Expand full comment
Devon's avatar

As an effeminate man, reading this made my heart sing!

Expand full comment
Cory's avatar

Wonderfully written piece that sums up a lot of me. I enjoy wearing a little makeup to highlight my assets but I haven’t worn a dress since my sister’s first wedding almost 15 years ago. I Ike to think I’m the best of both worlds :)

Expand full comment
CarolynD's avatar

I'm bisexual. I'm attracted to butch women. It's not the same as being attracted to a man. Because men and butch women are not the same thing. Obviously! 🙄

The next time someone queries my sexuality by saying, "Surely a butch woman is just a wannabe man?" I'll direct them to this post.

Long live butch woman energy! ❤️

Expand full comment
Funder's avatar

Oh, I loved this one so much! I’m an afab non binary butch mom to a nine year old, and this whole thing resonated so much.

I find myself doing both the mom-things and the dad-things equally these days, at least when I’m outside with our kid. My husband is physically disabled, and he rarely leaves the house - it takes too many spoons, you know. But the dad roles feel just as right to me as the mom roles.

I had such a vivid flashback to That Dress in my own childhood. Mine was brown floral velour, and I thought it was so pretty when I saw it, but when it was on it felt so deeply wrong. Like wearing someone else’s skin, just like you said. I was never comfortable as a kid unless I was wearing jeans, a t shirt, and sneakers. (Now that I’m old and wise I wear soft pants!)

I think our main difference is that I would *love* a genie’s wish or a fully automated gay space communism that would let me have a dude’s body for a little while. I love my tits, I *adore* my pussy - but wouldn’t it be great to have a dick, just as a treat? They’re so funny looking, and you can write your initials in the snow! No? Just me? Ahhh, well 😅

Expand full comment
Alex Fallgren's avatar

I love absolutely everything about this on so many levels, and also because I am who I am, I have to recommend the book "Ariel Crashes a Train" by Olivia A. Cole to you because the protagonist is a teen butch girl who feels very much the same way about her gender as you've described. (It is kind of a heavy read, but beautiful.)

Expand full comment
Soren Skogen's avatar

Thanks for the book rec; I'm gonna check it out!

Expand full comment
Kate Woolfitt's avatar

This is wonderful. It made smile and it made me cry. Thanks so much for writing it.

Expand full comment
Anya's avatar

wonderful ❤️

Expand full comment
Heidi's avatar

I absolutely adore butches and the role they (including you, Heather) have played in my own queer development. I couldn't be who I am today without the influence of butch women, and what a shame that would be!

Expand full comment
Marge Anderson's avatar

A thousand likes for this. Love the momentum of your writing. And so, so happy to see a piece about butch energy, which I haven’t seen in so long. The joy and the strength of this piece!

Expand full comment
Amy - The Tonic's avatar

Heartwarming and beautifully written 🧡

Expand full comment
Grover Wehman-Brown's avatar

Yes. <3 this. Thanks for this Heather.

Expand full comment
Meg Jones Wall // 3am.tarot's avatar

i love this so, so much

Expand full comment
Jenn Trivette's avatar

Beautifully written. Thank you

Expand full comment